|Photo Credit-Google Images
Mark Behnke-Battle Creek County
Commissioner refuses to give up
seat while running for City
Commissioner, at the same time.
over, controversy still remains in Battle Creek Michigan as a sitting
County Commissioner won one of 4 at-large seats on the Battle Creek City
Commission. Mark Behnke-(Republican) who had previously served on the Battle
Creek City Commission; (which also included him doing 2 stints as Mayor), was
elected as a County Commissioner in 2010. County Commission terms are 2 years
and are partisan elections.
non-partisan. Mark Behnke decided to run for City Commission while still less
then halfway through his County Commission term. When Behnke announced
his candidacy for City Commission, questions arose about him serving
on 2 boards and the conflict of interest it would create. Before the City
Commission election even took place, Behnke had stated that if he was elected
to the City Commission, he would step down from the County Commission position.
from either position. Battle Creek City Attorney, Eileen Wicklund contacted
the Attorney General’s Office in regards to Michigan’s incompatible office law.
The Michigan Attorney General‘s office deemed the two offices incompatible
because of contracts between the city and county.
individual attempting to serve in this dual capacity must vacate one of the
incompatible offices,” Richard Bandstra, chief legal counsel for Michigan
Attorney General Bill Schuette, said in the letter to the City Attorney. Behnke
disagrees and is using a previous attorney general’s opinion from 1996 that he
feels supports his right to hold both offices.
campaign he stated that he would step down from the County Board if elected to
the city to avoid a special election , he now says that he is unsure which
position he will leave.
action against a person who fails to leave an elected position after being
notified of a conflict of interest or incompatibility issue. The local
newspaper, The Battle Creek Enquirer ran a editorial here:
that in their opinion this issue needs to be resolved and that they feel that
Mark Behnke should resign from the County Commission. Mark Behnke suggested
holding a ’round table’ discussion that would be open to the public, seeking
input from residents and their perspective on the issue. His post on his
facebook as of Dec. 9th states as follows:
be some interest in my serving as a City Commissioner and County Commissioner.
Some people and businesses are being very vocal on this subject. Some
individauls look forward to an idea of working together in goverment to make
our County and City better. I would like to see if there’s any interest in
having a “round table” disucssion that would be open to the public.
By having a round table disucssion we would be able to see a lot of individuals
perspective on this issue. Please let me know if you would be interested in particpating
in a round table disucussion. Please let me know if you have any
Mr. Behnke ran for City Commission while still serving on the County Commission
is because he was rather bitter about not being selected as Chair of the County
Commission. So he went back to his old stomping grounds of 18 years and hoped
to become Mayor, which also didn’t happen.
It is this authors opinion
that with Mr. Behnke’s ‘waffling’ it appears that he may
believe that he is an exception to the rules and is just power hungry. At
the least he is playing political games for whatever reason or smokey back room
deals that could be taking place on the County Board for his possible
replacement. At the worst, he may have lied to a lot of people when he stated
that he would step down from the county commission should he be elected to the
city. Either way, Mr. Behnke is appearing to be disingenuous to say the least.